Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Because Facebook's Android App Could Read Users' Entire Photo Galleries Without Clear Consent
Italy's privacy regulator says a Facebook feature that suggests photos to post from a phone's gallery was switched on by default behind a vague permission prompt that could expose about 20 million Android users' photo libraries. It is the regulator's biggest fine on record. Meta says it will appeal.
Published
Last updated / Fact-checked on

Illustrative photo of an Android phone's app screen. It does not show the Facebook feature at the center of the Italian case.
Italy's data protection authority has hit Meta with an €805 million fine over a small Facebook feature that, according to the regulator, quietly gave the company the keys to millions of people's photo libraries.
The Garante per la protezione dei dati personali announced on Saturday, Nov. 14, that it had fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited for the way the Facebook app for Android accessed photos, videos and their metadata on Italian users' phones. The regulator said Meta did this "without obtaining specific consent and without properly informing them."
The amount, about $887 million according to BBC and Al Jazeera, is by far the largest fine the Italian regulator has ever imposed, Al Jazeera reported. Meta told the BBC it plans to appeal.
At a glance
| Item | Detail | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Fine | €805 million (about $887 million) | Garante; BBC, Al Jazeera |
| Company fined | Meta Platforms Ireland Limited | Garante |
| Feature | "Get tips from your gallery while browsing Facebook," on Android, available since 2023 | Garante |
| Users affected | About 20 million Android users in Italy | Garante |
| Law cited | Article 122 of Italy's Privacy Code, which implements the EU ePrivacy Directive | Garante |
| Deadline to fix | 60 days | Garante |
| Share of revenue | About 0.47% of Meta's global turnover | Garante |
| Meta's response | Disagrees and plans to appeal | BBC |
A suggestion box with a master key
The feature looks harmless. While someone scrolls Facebook, it offers photos and videos from their phone's gallery as ideas for a new post. The Garante calls it "Get tips from your gallery while browsing Facebook" and says it has been available since 2023.
The problem, according to the regulator, was how Facebook got permission to do this. Its technical analysis found three things:
- Gallery access was requested through a single permission that covered the whole app and several features with different needs.
- That permission came after a generic notice, "enable other features," that did not tell users they were also agreeing to gallery suggestions.
- The suggestion feature was turned on by default.
The Garante said the scope of that permission is what makes it serious. If fully granted, it "allows the app to read the entire photo archive on the device, usually permanently," and neither the user nor the regulator can check what information is actually being used.
Why the phone itself counts
The case rests on Article 122 of Italy's Privacy Code, the national version of the EU's ePrivacy Directive. The Garante said that rule treats a smartphone as part of a person's private sphere, so any access to what is stored on it needs free and informed consent. That applies "regardless of data transmission or the existence of harm," the regulator said. In other words, the violation is the access itself, whether or not the photos ever leave the phone.
That legal choice also decided who gets to rule. Meta argued that the case belonged to the Irish data protection authority instead. The Garante rejected that objection, saying the ePrivacy rules do not provide for the "one-stop shop" mechanism that would send the case to Ireland.
What Meta has to change
The regulator gave Meta 60 days to:
- ask for consent through a separate, specific request for this feature, explaining what it does, that it involves gallery access and how to turn it off;
- keep the feature off by default, including for people who have already granted the permission.
If Meta misses the deadline, the feature cannot be turned on for users who have not given valid consent. Meta must also tell the Garante within 30 days what it has started doing and within 90 days what it has done.
How the regulator got to €805 million
The Garante listed the factors behind the amount: the large number of people involved, about 20 million Android users in Italy; how long the violation lasted, which it said is still going on for people who have not updated the app and for those who already gave permission; a previous 2019 ruling against the company; and what it called limited cooperation during the investigation.
It counted changes Meta made after the complaint as a mitigating factor but judged them late and limited to people who update the app. The fine equals about 0.47% of the group's global revenue, the regulator said.
The case began in July 2025 with a complaint from the Bolzano consumer protection center, the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, according to the Garante.
Meta pushes back
Meta rejected the regulator's view. "We strongly disagree with the [regulator's] assessment of the facts, its application of the law, and the disproportionate level of the fine," the company told the BBC. "This is a straightforward feature which helps people post photos and videos to Facebook. People must give permission on their device before it can operate, and they can change this permission at any time via their settings."
The fine comes a month after a much larger legal blow. BBC reported that a judge in New Mexico ordered Meta to pay $25 billion after finding it had spent years misleading the public about how it handled Facebook user data.
The AI question the regulator left open
One issue the Garante explicitly did not decide is AI. Its proceedings "did not concern the potential use of content to train artificial intelligence," the regulator said, adding that Meta denies doing so.
But the regulator signaled that it is not finished. It said it "reserves the right to evaluate separately the new feature, launched in 2026, that allows cloud processing of gallery content." That distinction matters. The fined feature suggests photos from the phone itself; the newer one processes gallery content in Meta's cloud, which raises different questions about where private images go and how they are used.
Why it matters
The case is a reminder that broad app permissions can grant far more access than the feature they are requested for. According to the Garante, a single Android permission, granted once behind a vague prompt, could open a person's whole photo archive to the app. The regulator treated that permission design itself, not any transfer of data, as the violation.
The jurisdiction ruling may matter as much as the fine. By grounding the case in the ePrivacy rules, the Garante acted on its own rather than handing the matter to Ireland. If that reasoning holds up on appeal, other national regulators could take the same route against app features that reach into phones.
What to watch
Watch for Meta's appeal and whether a court suspends the 60-day orders, whether Meta changes the feature across the EU or only in Italy, and whether the Garante opens a formal case into the 2026 cloud-processing feature. Also watch whether other EU privacy regulators bring ePrivacy cases over similar gallery or camera-roll features.
How we reported this
DailyMech read the Garante's Nov. 14 press release in full, in both its Italian and English versions, along with BBC's and Al Jazeera's reports. Findings, orders and figures come from the Garante unless otherwise attributed. Meta's statement is quoted as given to the BBC. DailyMech did not examine the Facebook feature directly and contacted no one for this article.
Published November 14, 2026. Facts checked against the cited sources by DailyMech's AI writer.
Sources
- Facebook: il Garante privacy sanziona Meta per 805 milioni di euro, Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, press release, Rome, Nov. 14, 2026, with English version on the same page (fully read).
- Italy fines Meta €805m over accessing users' photos, George Wright, BBC News, Nov. 14, 2026 (fully read).
- Italy fines Meta $880m over photo privacy, Al Jazeera Staff, AFP and Reuters, Al Jazeera, Nov. 14, 2026 (fully read).
DailyMech used AI tools to research and draft this article. Facts were checked against the cited sources by DailyMech's AI writer, not by a human editor.